Larry Couchmanos was an extremely old fashioned man
despite his young age of 24. He was
raised with traditional European values that have seemed to disappear in America . He still believed in chivalrous acts like
walking women home, holding doors for them, letting them go in an elevator
first, etc. etc. As he became more and
more infuriated by the feminist movement however, he made some
concessions. He sometimes would sit down
on a subway even when there were women who were standing and sometimes he would
give in when being scolded for his archaic views by women who didn’t know him
well enough to know he was not doing it out of flirtation but because it was
the right thing to do.
On
one particular occasion, Larry went over to his friend’s Gia’s house to keep
her company since she was confined to her bed after a car had ran over her knee
twice. Gia’s two friends, Dara and Gabrielle
also came to visit Gia. Larry knew both
of them and got along with them but all three understood that they were not
friends with each other but merely shared a mutual close friend. This allowed them to be civil with each other
but not to call each other to hang out without Gia’s presence. When it came time to come home, Dara got in
her car and headed back to New Jersey while Larry
and Gabrielle started walking uptown starting from Gia’s apartment on 59th
and Sutton Place
in Manhattan , New York .
Larry lived on 70th and 2nd Avenue and Gabrielle lived
on 78th and 2nd.
Around 74tth Street, Gabrielle asked Larry, “Don’t you live
around here?”
“Yea,
I live on 70th but whatever I’ve already gone far enough, I might as
well just walk you to your door.”
This
had been Larry’s intention all along but he knew that Gabrielle, despite being
100% Italian, was a new-age woman that got offended by chivalry. Larry tried to subvert the argument secretly
knowing that it would never succeed. Gabrielle immediately responded back, “No,
you don’t have to do that, I’m so close to home, go home, I’m fine!”
“Yea,
that’s why you said you wanted to walk along York because you’re afraid of going under the
Queensborough bridge on 1st
Avenue .”
“Well
we didn’t go that way, we went on York ,
now we’re past the bridge, so I’m fine, you can go home now.”
“It’s
really not a problem, I’m closer to your place than mine anyway.”
The
argument continued like this but since they were walking, inherently Larry was
winning because they were getting closer and closer to Gabrielle’a
apartment. When they got to across the
street from her apartment, Gabrielle stopped and said, “I’m picking up some
food from the store, you certainly don’t have to follow me in there, I
literally live across the street.”
Larry
was fed up with this debate so decided to acquiesce and go home. When she finished getting a couple items from
the store and left a man came up from behind her and she felt something pointy
in her back. The man said, “Hey hunny,
what’s up?”
Gabrielle
didn’t recognize the voice but before she could turn her head to see who it was
he was whispering in her ear, “If you make one move or an effort to scream or
call for help, I’ll slice your fucking spine and you’ll be a vegetable for the
rest of your life. Gabrielle’s muscles tightened up and her arms began to
shake. The man continued, “now let’s
just go to our apartment as if we’re good friends.”
Gabrielle
crossed the street and fumbled with her keys hand shaking. The guy said in a stern whisper, “Relax! I’m
not going to hurt you, stop shaking and just unlock the door.”
Gabrielle
unlocked the front door to her apartment and they walked in. The man said, “If you knock on a door, I’ll
know you went to a neighbor’s apartment and not yours so don’t try anything
stupid.”
Gabrielle
led him to her apartment and unlocked the door and they crossed the threshold
and the man closed the door behind him and locked it. He lowered the object from her back and
shoved Gabrielle forward. Gabrielle,
being only 5’ tall and extremely petite, fell from the push.. The man grabbed her purse and removed her
cell phone and put it in his pocket. Gabrielle
was sitting with her feet up hugging her knees visibly frightened. She said, “Whatever you want, you can have
it? Whatever you see it’s yours, just
please take it and go.”
“But
I want to fuck you.”
Gabrielle’s
eyes widened. Her eyes started tearing
up and she said, “You don’t have to do this, I have jewelry and money, just
please go into my purse and take my wallet.
Please just don’t hurt me, you don’t have to hurt me, I won’t tell
anybody about you. I swear.”
The
man shook his head and walked toward Gabrielle who froze in fear. Gabrielle could now see the object that she
knew was pressed against her back. It
was a three inch serrated knife. The man
kicked Gabrielle in the chest between her legs and pinned her onto her
back. He applied slight pressure on her
sternum with his right foot and hissed, “You don’t tell me what to do, this is
not a negotiation, I can do whatever the fuck I want to you, and you will do
whatever I say whether you want to or not.”
“Why
me? Why are you doing this?”
“Because
I can.”
The
man lifted Gabrielle’s right leg and pulled off her sneaker and sock. He repeated the motion with her left shoe and
sock. Gabrielle kicked both legs into
his chest and turned to crawl away. She
didn’t have much force behind the kick, however, and the man recovered quickly and
grabbed her right leg and slammed his fist into her hamstring. He then bent her knee back lifted her leg as
far as he could and slammed her knee into the ground saying, “You want to kick
me with these chicken legs.”
He
repeatedly slammed her knee into the ground and let go. Gabrielle turned onto her back and grabbed at
her leg crying in pain. She wished that
someone would come help her, but the knife scared her. She knew that nobody would be able to get to
her quick enough if the man decided to kill her. The man then grabbed her left leg and twisted
it turning her back to her stomach and treated her left leg the same way he did
her right. He was talking low but
sternly, “You want to kick me bitch, how dare you! apologize now.”
Gabrielle
wanted the pain to stop so she cried out, “I’m sorry, I’m sorry.”
The
man grabbed her hair and yanked it up.
Instinctively, Gabrielle got up to her hands and knees as her knees
seared with pain. The man grabbed her
beneath the armpits and picked her up onto her feet. He then wrapped his left arm across her
stomach gripping her opposite waist and used his right arm to scoop up her legs
so she was parallel to the floor. He
lifted her up and slammed her back over his knee and smiled. He said, “See what all that dieting and
exercising and watching your figure get you?
It just makes it so much easier for guys like me to manhandle you” as he
stood up and slammed her back over his knee again. He used his forearms to press down against
her chest and thighs to stretch her body and add more torque to her back. Gabrielle was in too much pain to scream so
she just gagged between sobs pleading in a barely audible whisper, “Please
stop.”
The
man shoved her body off her and Gabrielle made no attempt to control her body
and lied motionless as she rolled twice before resting on her back. The man straddled her legs and undid her belt
followed by unbuttoned and unzipped her pants.
Gabrielle stopped resisting, she was in a lot of pain and figured the
more she fought, the more she’d get hurt.
The man pulled her pants off her.
He then grabbed her arms and pulled her up. Gabrielle made no attempt to stand as she
just let her momentum carry her to lean against him. He gripped the bottom of her shirt and pulled
it over her head and tossed it to the side.
“There’s a good bitch” he said
He
bent over and wrapped his arms around her legs and hoisted her over his
shoulder and carried her to the bedroom and slammed her on the bed. He reached around and undid her bra and
removed it from her body exposing her breasts.
He smiled and said, “Damn, I thought you’d put up a little bit more
fight than this.”
He
rolled her onto her stomach and straddled her back facing her feet. He gripped the top of her underwear and
pulled it toward him. The fabric wedged between her buttocks baring it. The man yanked again on the panties. He let go of the panties and slapped his
hands onto her bare buttock squeezing with every collision. He motioned Gabrielle back to her feet and
picked her up by the arms over his head and dropped her gripping her
panties. Gabrielle fall was stopped as
fabric wedged further into her and she heard a ripping noise. The man repeated it two more times until the
elastic band came clean off and Gabrielle’s feet were returned to the
ground. The man pulled the fabric out of
her buttocks and since the elastic band was now being worn as a necklace by him
and not holding the panties in place, they fell to her ankles. He shoved her
onto the bed again as the panties slipped over her ankles and to the ground. Gabrielle now lay on the bed completely
nude. The man stripped himself of his
clothing and sat down on the bed next to Gabrielle’s body. Gabrielle was sobbing uncontrollably, but the
man didn’t seem to care. The man grabbed
her arms and pulled her to a seated position.
He then turned her toward him and spread her out on his lap so that her
waist was resting on his right leg and her breasts over his left leg. He pressed down with his left hand on her
shoulder blades to hold her in place and spanked her with his right hand
saying, “You’ve been a bad little bitch haven’t you?”
After
being spanked a few times, Gabrielle cried out in desperation, “Please just get
it over with!”
The
man chuckled and said, “What’s that? You
want to fuck me slut?”
Gabrielle
said nothing. The man shoved her onto
the ground lying on her stomach and picked up her right leg and lied down
wrapping his legs around her right leg and gripping her foot in his hand. He twisted the ankle and squeezed his thighs
to limit any movement Gabrielle may have in her leg. Gabrielle screamed out in pain. The man said, “Tell me you want to fuck me” Gabrielle
howled in pain and gagged trying to find the words. The man continued, “Say it, or I’ll break
your fucking ankle.”
Gabrielle
cried out in a whisper, “Fuck me”
“Say
please”
“Please”
“Louder!!!
Scream out ‘please fuck me’”
“PLEASE
FUCK ME!!!” Gabrielle screamed and then cried hysterically
“Tell
me you’re a slut”
“Please
just let go”
“Scream
it”
“I’m
a slut!” she yelled out
The
guy let go of her leg and stood up. He
stripped himself nude and knelt beside her nudging his knee into her side and
brought his arm under hers and gripping the back of her leg and motioned her
onto her back. He slipped his arms under
her legs and neck and hoisted her up dead weight and placed her on the
bed. He looked at her and said, “Well if
you insist” as he lied on top of her inserting his penis into her vagina.
Gabrielle
squealed in pain and continued to cry.
She wanted it to stop but knew telling him was fruitless. In desperation she wanted to speed things up
so said, “You need to be quick before my boyfriend gets home.”
She
lived alone and was bluffing but hoped he wouldn’t know that. The guy slapped her across the face and said,
‘You live alone bitch, if you had a boyfriend, you’d never say that because
you’d want him to catch me so that he could rescue you. I hope you do have a boyfriend though, so
that I can kick his ass and then fuck you as he watches on helplessly.” Gabrielle
said nothing and he continued, “I love this part. Up until this part you little bitches
actually think it might not happen, something will stop me from actually
penetrating, but then I do and the reality sets in. How does it feel?”
Gabrielle
didn’t know what the correct answer was so said nothing. She didn’t want to get hit again. The man was driving his penis into her while
caressing and sucking on her breasts.
She let her body go limp and conceded to everything he wanted. The man wrapped her legs around his waist and
thrusted harder as Gabrielle’s lower body lifted with his. Mercifully, she believed, he stopped only to
be turned onto her stomach and have him drive his penis into her butt. Her vaginal walls had been torn and blood
flowed onto her sheets. It didn’t take
long for the skin on her buttocks to tear and bleed as well. He lifted her so that she was on her hands
and knees so he could squeeze her breasts and kiss her neck as he propelled his
penis repeatedly into her buttocks. He
then alternated between sticking it her butt and her vagina from behind. Finally she heard him gag as he climaxed and
ejaculated sperm into her rectum. He
rolled over onto his back and breathed heavily.
Gabrielle cried harder now that her ordeal was over.
Finally,
the man stood up. Gabrielle thought he
was going to leave but instead he dragged her off the bed by her legs and let
the top half of her body slam against the ground. Gabrielle’s nose started bleeding from the
impact with the floor. She came to the
sad realization that he wasn’t done with her. The man yanked her by the hair and
motioned her to her feet. He applied
pressure on her neck so that she bent before him and stuck her head between his
legs. He reached around her waist and
pulled up on her stomach and brought her body around so that it straddled his
face and then threw her down to the ground onto her neck and head. She grabbed her head and rolled onto the
ground in pain. As she was rolling, she
was stopped by a foot on her side and found herself being motioned up
again. He stood behind her and wrapped
his arm around her stomach and the other arm on the back of her legs and
flipped her over his shoulder so that her stomach lie on his shoulder spread
out parallel to the ground held in place by one arm on her lower back. He carried her out of her room to a table and
lied her down on her back. Gabrielle
hadn’t noticed before, but the man had a plastic bag with him when he came
in. He went to the front door and
removed duct tape from it. Gabrielle was
in too much pain to move when he left the room so was exactly where he had left
her when he returned. He spread her arms
over her head and wrapped the duct tape around her arms, and the table
continuing it for her entire arm, forehead, neck, stomach and legs. She looked down and realized that he only
didn’t wrap her breasts, face and groin in duct tape. He picked up her purse and said, “You know
what, I think I will take you up on that offer to give me money.” Gabrielle’s eyes widened, when she originally
proposed it, it was to take that instead of killing or raping her as he already
had done the latter. The man smiled, and
opened her wallet and removed the cash.
He then took out the debit card and said, ‘What’s the code?”
Gabrielle
said, “Come on, you’ve already won”
“Hey
you asked me to fuck you, I should at least be paid for it. I mean you are a new-aged woman after all,
you believe that woman should pay for men now right?”
“She
looked at him with contempt. She decided
that there was nothing more he could do to her so there was no reason not to
talk back. She said, “What makes you
think I’m new-age? You got what you
wanted, you fucked me, what more could you want.”
“Money”
he said simply
“Well
fuck you.”
The
man realized that Gabrielle believed she had nothing to lose anymore. He was going to change that theory. He stood over her and urinated on her face
and neck. He then straddled her and
brought the knife across the duct tape on her left wrist. The knife cut through the tape and the skin
and blood began dripping onto the table.
Gabrielle’s strength left her and she became frightened again. He put the knife against her right wrist and
said, “The code?”
“You
don’t have to do this?”
“Well
obviously, it’s probably just your birthday, but I don’t want to go to the ATM
and then have it not be your birthday and come back so just tell me or I could
just continue to cut you. You’re
cuteness means nothing to me now, I’ve already fucked you and the more I
disfigure you, the more likely that I will be the last one to do so. I’ll give you five second..5…4”
Gabrielle
said, “It’s my birthday. 11-23
The
man laughed and said, “Wrong answer” and drove the knife across her wrist
again. He got off her and picked up her
purse again and removed her driver’s license from the window. He held it up to her face and said, “Bitch,
it says 11-20-83 on the license, did you forget your birthday? Or you just decided to lie to me?”
Before
Gabrielle could answer, he put a sheet of duct tape over her mouth and walked
toward the bedroom to get dressed. He
looked around the apartment and didn’t see a phone so he reached into her purse
and took out her cell phone and put it in his pocket along with the debit card
and her keys. He put a ski mask on and
went to an ATM and withdrew the maximum $ 600.
He returned to the apartment and dropped the card and the keys to the
ground. Gabrielle was still bound to the
table. He fanned the $ 600 in front of
her face and said, “Thanks for a nice night whore”
He
then took his knife and went under the table and cut the duct tape and pulled
it unsympathetically off of Gabrielle’s body.
He then slid his arms under her legs and neck and carried her to the
bathroom and started the shower. He
thoroughly bathed her getting rid of all DNA evidence. He didn’t bother to shut off the water and
left Gabrielle lying in the tub with the shower splashing off her naked
body. The man then left the apartment
and shut the door.
Gabrielle
cried hysterically and was too weak to pick herself up. After a while she mustered the courage to
crawl out of her bathroom and to her purse to take out her cell phone only to
realize that the man didn’t return it.
She was left with no phone to call someone for help. She needed a hospital but she couldn’t stand. As she lay on the ground she relived the
night in her mind. Although the rape was
predominant in her mind, the one thing she thought about was how she snapped at
Larry to not walk her to her apartment.
She tried to tell herself that Larry wouldn’t have been able to stop him
but she did believe it to be a little too coincidental that in the couple
minutes it took to get a couple groceries and walk across the street, someone
had targeted her. She refused to blame
herself, however, as she convinced herself that if Larry hadn’t walked her as
far as he did, she never would have argued with him and she never would have
caught the attention of the rapist. She
had no proof of any of this, but proof never stood in the way of a woman’s
opinion before, so why should it now?
She
was only half awake as she allowed herself to be semi-unconscious so she
wouldn’t feel the pain. She got a sudden
surge of adrenaline and screamed out, “Call an ambulance, come in by any means
necessary, please help me.”
Given
that people don’t like getting involved, nobody came to her aid. Eventually the wounds inside of her became
infected and she died a slow agonizing death. A few days later, neighbors
called because of the smell. By that
time, it had been too long for any worthwhile forensics and the killer was
never caught.