Tuesday, December 17, 2019

Real Characters Episode 36 IG Report puts Democrats in a Bad Situation


                A Democrat house member is watching the House Judiciary committee vote on whether or not to proceed in an impeachment vote next week.  As she watches, she hopes that the committee will do the right thing and not put her in an awkward situation despite all indications being that that is exactly what they are going to do.  Sure enough, the house judiciary committee passes the resolution and the Democrat congresswoman buries her head in her hands.  On her desk is a giant stack of paper that is the Department of Justice Inspector General (IG) Michael Horowitz’s report about the origins of the investigation into Donald Trump and Russia collusion.  This is a document that she has read and even gave portions to her staff to read just in case she missed something. 

                She calls a meeting with her staff and advises the last one in to close the door.  She starts, “This conversation cannot leave this room.  There are some extremely powerful people that may not like what we say in here so it’s better that we just keep this between us.  Is that clear?”

                There is unanimous nodding and assent then she asks, “Does anyone have anything concrete in the IG report that supports his conclusion that it was predicated correctly?”

                There is a silence as her staff members look at each other.  Finally, one of her staffers who will be named Gus, offers, “Actually Ma’Ame, I think that the Horowitz report debunks itself.”

                “Yea, that’s what I got too.  It’s over 400 pages of egregious errors and lies by the FBI then the conclusion is that everything is honky dory.”

                “Besides that, even the bottom line on the reason it was opened was ridiculous”

                “How do you mean?”

                “Well, the FBI claimed, and Horowitz confirmed, that the predication of the investigation was legitimate because of the Downer meeting and not the dossier.”

                “Yes”

                “If you look at footnote 461, it completely contradicts that.”

                “What does it say?”

                “It’s long, so I’ll break it up.   It starts, “The only express direction we found that McCabe gave regarding the use of a CHS concerned a former FBI CHS who contacted an FBI agent in a field office in late July 2016 to report information from a ‘a colleague who runs an investigative firm…hired by two entities, The DNC as well as another individual who was not named, to explore Donald Trump’s longstanding ties to Russian entities.’  That is clearly referring to Christopher Steele as the confidential human source (CHS) and his colleague is Glenn Simpson and Fusion GPS since we know they were hired by the DNC and Hillary Clinton.”

                “I’m not sure why that contradicts the story.”

                “The investigation was open in July 2016 so McCabe is giving these express directions at the same time the investigation is open.”

                “I guess it could have been about something else but I’m not willing to give them the benefit of the doubt anymore.”

                “Whether that is what started the investigation or not, it proves the FBI lied that they never got a hold of the dossier until September 2016.”

                The congresswoman’s tone turned sarcastic, “Great, even the footnotes expose the FBI for being liars.”

                A female staffer we will call ‘Miranda’ expresses, “I saw the same footnote.  The rest of it isn’t any better than the first.  It goes on, ‘The former CHS also gave the FBI agent a list of ‘individuals and entities who have surfaced in (the investigative firm’s) examination, which the former CHS described as ‘mostly public source material.’  In mid-September 2016, McCabe told SSA 1 to instruct the FBI agent from the field office not to have any further contact with the former CHS, and not to accept any information regarding the Crossfire Hurricane investigation.  McCabe told the OIG he did not remember giving those instructions, and could not tell us why he might have done so.  We found no evidence that the FBI reopened the former CHS for the Crossfire Hurricane investigation or asked the former CHS connection with the Crossfire Hurricane investigation.’  Based on this, it appears that September wasn’t the beginning of their talks with Steele but the end of it. 

                The congresswoman sighs, “Now the Deputy Director is changing his story but there’s got to be a reason Horowitz said that.  That means in September, they knew that Steele was full of shit; so much so, the Deputy Director is telling the FBI field office and agent that heard the original information to cut ties with him.  Then, they open a FISA in October anyway.”

                Miranda responds, “It would appear so.  It turns out that the only direction from the Deputy Director had nothing to do with Papadopoulos but was about not talking to Steele anymore.  Remember, the first part that it was the only direct correspondence regarding Steele.”

                Gus adds, “What I’m beginning to think happened, and this is based on what Bill Barr has been saying, is that on September 19, 2016, McCabe figures out that everything he based his investigation on is bogus but he needs an excuse on why he opened it.  He’s been sitting on a cable he heard from Downer on May 10, 2019 when he heard Papadopoulos say that the Russians had dirt on Hillary.  He plays that card because the dossier was so discredited and that’s all he had.”

                “Why wouldn’t it be in the IG report then?”

                “Horowitz limited his investigation to things that happened after the end of May 2016.  The Downer cable was early May so he wouldn’t have had it.”

                “So, it was decided in September that the new story is Downer.  Despite that, they opened four FISA’s on Carter Page based on the Dossier.  Why?”

                Miranda answers, “They thought the FISA would uncover something they could actually use.  You know, an ‘ends justifies the means’ strategy.”

                “Why sit on the cable with Downer?”

                Gus rejoins, “They tried using it to open a FISA on Papadopoulos and got turned down.  They knew it wasn’t enough for a FISA so they didn’t think it was useful.”

                The congresswoman nods, “The Downer cable was good enough to open an investigation but the Steele information was good enough for the FISA so they lied about the dates they heard these things to link them to the appropriate actions.”

                “Exactly”

                “Now, I have to vote to impeach this guy when I know that everything they’ve said about him has been a lie.”

                Miranda retorts, “Well, the impeachment is about Ukraine.”

                “Did those hearing make you believe there’s any more substance to that than Russian collusion?”

                “Well no it didn’t.”

                “But if I vote against it, then I help President Trump and I really don’t like him.  You can’t impeach because you personally don’t like someone though can you?”  There is silence and the congresswoman is frustrated, “If I abstain, I look weak.  Damn Pelosi for putting me in this situation.  Why couldn’t she just stand firm against Schiff and Nadler?  Their districts are filled with radical Democrats that wouldn’t vote Republicans even if the Democrat candidate waterboarded their mothers.  I have a week to decide but I’m really at a loss.  Does anybody have any advice on which way I should go?”

                The room was deathly silent that even a slight shift in the chair due to discomfort sounded like thunder.

 

                The Democrat Congresswoman isn’t the only one that has read the IG Report.  Glenn Greenwald of the Intercept has as well.  He is speaking to his editor and declares, “I need to write a hit piece on the media, the FBI and everyone that has defended the Russian collusion hoax.”

                “We can’t support President Trump.  There are a lot of powerful people that you’re going to piss off if you rattle that cage.”

                “I don’t care.  You know that my number one loyalty is to Civil Rights violations and this is probably the worst Civil Rights Violation in American history.  If our law enforcement won’t prosecute the FBI, then the media has to.  That is our job.”

                “I admire your zeal but it is very risky.”

                “Don’t patronize me.”

                “It’s just that we have been running short of donors.  This outlet is on fumes and since we’re vulnerable, we can be crushed by these powerful people.”

                “Sounds to me like these powerful people haven’t been helping you out.  Why not rebrand ourselves as not being an echo chamber for all the other mainstream outlets and speak the truth.  What do we have to lose?  You said it yourself; the paper is desperate for money.  Mindlessly listening to the New York Times, Washington Post, CNN, ABC, and MSNBC have gotten us nowhere.”

                The editor contemplates this a moment and realizes there is merit.  He finally utters, “Keep the focus on the FBI.”

                “The first half will be the FBI, the second half with be the media.”

                “We can’t attack our own.  You need to work with me a little bit on this.  I’m agreeing to the article against my better judgment, you need to give me something in return.”

                “What if I use the attack on the media as an attack on the FBI too.”

                “How are you going to do that?”

                “Claim that the media’s problem isn’t that they’re biased or a propaganda arm for the Democrat party like the conservatives imply, but their problem is they keep hiring former-FBI and CIA agents that cover for their original employer.”

                The editor nods, “That can work.”

                “Thank you, I’ll get on it right away.”

                On December 12, 2019, the intercept publishes the article “The Inspector General Report on 2016 FBI Spying Reveals a Historic Magnitude: Not Only for the FBI but Also the US Media.”  Greenwald pulls no punches in attacking the FBI dating back to when they tried to blackmail Martin Luther King Jr. into killing himself to their renewing the FISA three times in 2017 by not only continuing on the seven major omissions and inaccuracies by the FBI but adding 10 additional errors based on known information between the first application and the renewals.

                When the editor reads it he rubs his eyes, “Well, you did what you said.  This is pretty damning.  I know this is an important topic to you but was the dossier information really that bad?”

                “Sir, Steele’s own sub-source that gave him the information told the FBI that he didn’t remember saying anything about Wikileaks and Trump never talked to the Kremlin.  Then, the coup-de-grat, they never talked about the Roseneft bribe, which was the only crime alleged thus completing the qualifications for a FISA.  The sub-source proved that Steele lied about everything and disproved the entire document.”

                “How could the FBI be this stupid?”

                “Being stupid is the best analysis of this.  If they’re not stupid, then it means they knowingly committed federal crimes to spy on Americans and given the intense admissions process of the FBI, it would appear the second option is more valid.  Unfortunately, there is no third option.”

 

                Back in the congresswoman’s office, she realizes that nobody is going to answer her.  She articulates, “Alright, we’ll work our way there another way.  Let’s look at the tone of the world.  Do they want us to impeach Donald Trump?”

                Gus takes this one, “Given Boris Johnson won multiple seats in Parliament and it seems that anyone promoting Brexit is winning elections, it would appear that the world is with Donald Trump and that globalist organizations like NATO and the EU are not popular anymore.”

                Miranda remarks, “Well, there’s an article in the Guardian that Britain needs its own Mueller Report on Russian interference.’”

                The congresswoman blurts out, “You’re kidding me!  After that debacle, the Brits want to replay that in their country?  Good luck.  That was an abomination and is kind of the beginning of the pickle we’re in now.  Why would England be so stupid as to replicate our mistakes?”

                Gus fired back, “It’s kind of what Glenn Simpson and Peter Fritsch do.  It’s what Fusion GPS does.”

                “This is a Fusion GPS investigation?”

                “They wrote the Guardian article.”

                “Wow, the balls on those two is legendary.  A day after the IG report eviscerated their dossier and everything they’ve told us for three years, they go across the pond and try it again.  Don’t they know that the whole world is interested in American politics?  Do they really think the world doesn’t know about what they did or the IG report?”

                “It’s not their first rodeo.  It’s not even their second.  The first time was against Bob Dole, then they did it to McCain but Bush shut it down, then Trump and now Boris Johnson.”

                “Unbelievable.  The first three weren’t as heavily publicized though. Hopefully they went to the well too many times.”

                Miranda blurted out, “Are you saying the Russian didn’t meddle in the elections?”

                Gus snapped back, “No, of course they did.  They do every time just as how we meddle in theirs.  The point is that neither our or Britain’s politicians are Russian assets.  Their economy is smaller than Italy’s; they are just not powerful enough to pull it off despite what Hollywood will have you believe that they are faking how weak they are.  Russia doesn’t like us; we know that but it doesn’t mean we should devote all our resources to it.”

                The congresswoman tried to restore order among her staffers, “Let’s focus on us again.  It seems even the media is turning against the collusion advocates.  There was an article in the intercept and Rolling Stone saying the IG report exonerated Trump more than the FBI so to speak.  I’m guessing the Durham report isn’t going to do us any favors.”

                “That’s actually making the FBI look worse already” Gus commented

                “How so?”

                “Comey is refusing to reinstate his security clearance so that he can’t be asked questions since it relies on confidential information.  That’s how Comey escaped talking to the IG.”

                “Durham can subpoena him though.”

                “True but Bill Barr said it’s still a problem.”

                “Barr can just declassify everything he shows him.  This is all three years old anyway so Barr has a way of getting around that.”

                “He does, but it’s a slippery slope to declassify something.  Even if it’s only for a couple hours so they can question Comey. The whole world can find out in a couple hours with our communication capabilities now.”

                “What do the polls on impeachment say?”

                Miranda fields this one, “52% say not to impeach Trump after the second impeachment hearing.  This is in battleground states.”

                “That means that every time they had a hearing, the number against impeachment went up.”

                “Yes Ma’ame”

                “And to begin with, no Republicans voted for the impeachment inquiry and two Democrats voted against.  One of them was from New Jersey, which is pretty blue.”

                “Yes, that is true”

                “That makes it bipartisan against impeachment but not for.”

                “Correct, but the strength in the Democrats is our ability to stick together.  That’s something the Republicans have always been bad at.’

                “They seem to be unifying over this.  I guess the common enemy debate.  The Republicans were united in saying they were against; it is us that had defectors.  It’s not too surprising given who we have on our side.”

                The staffers look at each other thinking their boss just had a Freudian slip.  Gus is the only one that speaks up, “Yea, the squad is hurting us.”

                “It’s not just them; though they are pretty bad.  You have Hank Johnson from Georgia who actually thought Guam would sink if you put ships on it.  He gave a speech yesterday that Trump abused his power because he had a bigger chair than Ukrainian President Zelensky.  He actually insinuated that Zelensky was weak because at the UN meeting, President Trump was 6’4” so had a bigger chair than the 5’11” Zelensky.  I mean who says this shit?  We need to impeach the president because he’s too tall so too intimidating for shorter heads of other countries?”

                Gus pronounced, “Well, there are all these sciences about power moves during handshakes and stuff so I guess that’s what Johnson was getting at.”

                “Nobody recommended impeachment because of a power hand shake.  That actually is more damning than what Johnson said.  President Trump can’t help being 6’4” just as how Zelensky can’t help being 5’11.”  It’s also an insult to short people.  At least the hand shake is an action and not just an unchangeable fact.”

                “Yea, you’re right.  I got nothing.”

                “Then, you have that ass hat from Louisiana watching golf during the impeachment hearings.  He can’t even pretend that he was forced to be there by Nadler because he released a statement about how important and serious the hearings were and then he’s watching golf as it’s going on.”

                It was Miranda’s turn to try to refocus her, “We’re getting off topic.  Before the hearings, there were two Democrats that voted against the inquiry.  All indications are that about three more may join.  The question is, are you going to be one of them.”

                “I really don’t know.  I’m leaning that way.  I like being loyal but come on, AOC compared family leave policies to dogs.  She actually insinuated that since dogs get eight weeks with their puppies, humans should as well.”

                “Does she realize that dogs don’t work or get paid?” Gus inquired

                “Unclear.  She talks about how the market has failed when dogs get more family leave than humans.  Are you serious?  How do you even enforce this?  What happens if you don’t give a dog eight weeks?  Is there a government organization that reprimands you?  Do you get a fine?  How does a dog even sign a contract?” The room laughs including the congressman, “Come on, there’s loyalty and then there’s supporting that ridiculousness.  Ultimately though this is my decision so I need to determine if I’m going to be a good loyal Democrat and stay in line or if I’m going to do what I know to be the right thing even though it helps someone I loathe. 

No comments:

Post a Comment